“I actually was involved that it was over for me,” Billie Eilish confesses at a desk with Dua Lipa, Olivia Rodrigo, Jon Batiste, Cynthia Erivo and Julia Michaels, who got here collectively to debate their songwriting prowess and course of. “We’d been attempting and it wasn’t doing what it often would do in me. I used to be actually like, ‘Rattling, possibly I hit my peak and I don’t know write anymore?’ ” Struggling for inspiration, the 21-year-old had hit a wall, till Greta Gerwig known as in January with an project: Write a tune for Barbie. The consequence was the emotional and scene-stealing “What Was I Made For?” that Eilish wrote together with her brother and musical companion, Finneas. “Greta saved me, actually, actually,” Eilish says. “It introduced us out of it and instantly we had been impressed and wrote a lot extra after that.” A frontrunner for greatest unique tune on the 2024 Oscars, Eilish is joined by different contenders: Lipa, together with her disco bop “Dance the Night time,” additionally from Barbie; and Rodrigo — on a white-hot streak together with her GUTS album — who wrote the eerie and highly effective “Can’t Catch Me Now” for The Starvation Video games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes. Rounding out THR’s annual Songwriter Roundtable are Michaels, who has penned hits for Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez and wrote “This Want” (carried out by Ariana DeBose) for Disney’s Want; Grammy darling and Oscar winner Jon Batiste, who composed “It By no means Went Away” for the Netflix doc American Symphony, which follows Batiste at a profession excessive whereas his spouse battles leukemia; and Tony, Emmy and Grammy winner Cynthia Erivo, who wrote “It Would Be” for the indie movie Drift, which she stars in and produced.
THR Songwriters Cowl 32
Throughout an hourlong taping at The Georgian Resort in Santa Monica, the six performers traded tales about making music and extra, as Lipa coined the subgenre “dance-crying” and Batiste spoke concerning the therapeutic energy of music, pointing particularly to Eilish and Rodrigo as artists his spouse listened to whereas she underwent remedy for most cancers.
Do you bear in mind the primary tune or lyric you wrote?
CYNTHIA ERIVO I used to be 16 and wrote a tune known as “Perhaps,” and I believe it was given to a South African woman group or one thing. And I bear in mind (begins singing), “Have you ever ever thought that he would by no means name you in any respect as a result of he’s too good to be true …”
OLIVIA RODRIGO What the hell.
ERIVO (Nonetheless singing) “Fairly woman, you’re superb.” Yeah, I do not forget that.
JULIA MICHAELS We’re achieved.
RODRIGO That’s all.
Billie Eilish
Who needs to comply with that?
RODRIGO Rattling. I assume the primary tune that I wrote on piano, correct, I used to be most likely 14 or 15, and I wrote this feminist anthem known as “Superman,” about how I didn’t want Superman to come back and save me. Begin them younger.
BILLIE EILISH That’s proper.
JON BATISTE Heading in the right direction.
DUA LIPA Gosh. I imply, once I was about 4 or 5 years previous, I made up this tune. Albanian was my first language, and so I sang it in Albanian, and it was a tune I’d made for my mother. I’d stroll round the home, and I’d be like, “Once I develop up, can I borrow your sneakers? And once I develop up, can I put on your gown? And once I develop up, can I be similar to you?” It really simply caught round. It’s the one factor that, at residence, we simply all the time remind ourselves of.
RODRIGO That’s cute.
MICHAELS That’s lovely.
EILISH I like that.
How about you, Jon?
BATISTE I used to be doing numerous music, instrumentally, for a few years, and I began writing lyrics for a Shakespeare play that needed songs within the play. I used to be most likely about 21. I used to be like, “Man, characters and worlds and the expression of all these interconnected relationships, how can we make all these sounds come collectively?” That was the top of it. I liked that stuff.
EILISH The primary lyrics I bear in mind writing was most likely once I was 8 or one thing, and it was like (laughs and begins singing), “I’m taking place, down, down into the black gap, sweeping up your soul at present …”
Olivia Rodrigo
Have been you going by one thing on the time as an 8-year-old?
EILISH No. Pay attention, I used to be writing tales, man. I really feel like the primary tune that I wrote, I used to be 6, and it was me and my pal. We had been enjoying the ukulele and it was a tune about ukuleles. No matter. You guys have good tales.
MICHAELS I don’t actually have a very good story. I began writing once I was 6 as effectively, simply on a regular basis.
EILISH Simply dangerous little songs.
MICHAELS Yeah, actually, actually dangerous.
EILISH Me too, dude.
MICHAELS However the first [professional] factor I ever acquired was this theme tune for a Disney Channel present once I was 17, the present known as Austin & Ally.
RODRIGO Liked that tune.
LIPA And the remaining is historical past.
You all have superb movie songs which have been launched this 12 months. It’s the one centesimal anniversary of Disney, and also you wrote numerous music for Want, Julia. What was that like? And is it true you sang background vocals on “Let It Go” from Frozen?
MICHAELS I did, yeah.
RODRIGO That’s so cool.
LIPA That’s very cool.
MICHAELS I used to be 19 and doing demos across the metropolis to satisfy individuals and pay my hire. I acquired a name from somebody who was engaged on the Demi [Lovato] model of the tune. They had been like, “Hey, we’d like some backgrounds achieved for this tune. It’s for a Disney movie.” Humorous sufficient, 10 years later, reduce to the tune that I did background for, the film [Frozen] was directed by the identical folks that directed the movie [Wish] that I wrote all of the songs for.
Dua Lipa
Cynthia, you star in Drift and likewise produced the movie and wrote the unique tune. What was it like sporting so many hats?
ERIVO It was nuts. I all the time known as it “The Little Engine That Might” as a result of it was constructed from nothing, principally. Slightly indie film that we made on location in Greece, and we didn’t have a lot time to do it in. So I’m on set, fascinated with the schedule and ensuring that we will get photographs achieved, however attempting to be in scenes which can be actually powerful. However the tune was the simplest half for me as a result of it was impressed once I was on a run one morning. I listened to the tune by Laura Mvula known as “Father.” It linked with what I used to be experiencing and what this film was about. So I texted her — I didn’t inform anybody else [involved in the production] first, which isn’t what you’re purported to do. I used to be like, “Would you be into working with me on a tune for this?” She mentioned sure. Then I informed them.
Everyone seems to be so excited for the newest Starvation Video games movie. Olivia, what was the inspiration behind your tune?
RODRIGO It was a lot enjoyable. Most of my songs are very diaristic in nature and type of about my life. It was such a enjoyable problem to look at this film by the eyes of this character and attempt to seize her expertise by my phrases and my voice. There’s a lot inspiration in proscribing your self generally. I don’t know when you guys ever have this, however when you may have each shade within the palette and any canvas you need, it’s simply so overwhelming that generally I believe limiting your self really makes you assume outdoors the field and reinvent. I believe that’s one of many joys about writing a tune for a film — there’s this stunning storyline that you just get to paint in with your personal phrases.
Jon, your tune is a part of a documentary about you and your spouse. Inform us concerning the movie and the tune you wrote.
BATISTE It began out as one factor after which it modified — life got here into the image. I began to put in writing a symphony that was premiering at Carnegie Corridor, however a couple of month into filming, there have been numerous adjustments in my life personally, in addition to in my profession. It was the week of being notified of being nominated for 11 Grammys —
RODRIGO Informal.
MICHAELS Cas, tremendous cas.
BATISTE Individuals knew about that. They didn’t know my spouse acquired identified with leukemia. I bear in mind I acquired a name from President Biden, and we had been within the chemotherapy ward, and he was congratulating me concerning the nominations whereas we had been getting information about what her remedy can be. So we determined to maintain filming — it grew to become the symphony of life, how life has the duality of the highs and lows, generally , generally excessive highs and lows . She’s doing nice now, however when she was within the hospital, it was about two months the place we didn’t know if she was going to make it. And within the hospital, there are all these sounds — it’s beeps and all these individuals coming out and in, all of the issues that disturb your relaxation. So I began writing her these lullabies. She’s a author. She would really take heed to your music (factors to Rodrigo) and your music (factors to Eilish) whereas she painted. She began portray as a result of her imaginative and prescient was blurred from the treatment and she or he couldn’t write anymore. None of them had been meant to come back out, however the tune [“It Never Went Away”] got here from considered one of these lullabies. I thank y’all for what y’all do as a result of I used to be very conscious of the profundity of what we do in her therapeutic course of with music and creativity. Creativity as an act of survival. I imagine in that so strongly. I believed in it earlier than, however now I’m similar to, “Let’s go. Let’s make extra stunning issues.”
Cynthia Erivo
As creators, what’s it like once you hear that your music has actually helped somebody in a tough time?
EILISH It’s arduous to absorb.
MICHAELS Agree.
EILISH I discover myself …
MICHAELS Overwhelmed.
EILISH Yeah. I don’t actually know imagine it as a result of I do know what it’s wish to be in that place, and it’s so actual. And to assume that you just’re serving to any person who’s in that’s actually astounding and particular, and you are feeling, like, undeserving. I didn’t deserve that will help you by that. But it surely’s so particular and highly effective.
BATISTE That’s an effective way of placing it.
LIPA To be part of somebody’s expertise …
ERIVO It simply crystallizes it. It makes you focus in on the factor that you just’re really doing. So there’s a lot of noise across the precise artwork of creating one thing, making music, making movie, making TV, no matter it’s. However when an individual has taken the time to hear, to be there, meet you the place you’re at, meet you the place you had been once you made the factor, and take that with them of their every day life and use it as a instrument to assist them get by no matter they’re getting by, you’re part of their lives. You have got made one thing that sticks with them that they get to hold with them. That’s presumably some of the unimaginable honors you possibly can have. Which means rather a lot as a result of, for me if I’m sincere, I don’t know that you possibly can have informed me once I was 15, 16 that I might be right here. That I may make music and have individuals take heed to it. It was a pie-in-the-sky dream.
LIPA I really feel utterly the identical. I assumed it was as unrealistic as a cartoon on TV. I might watch artists and I’d be like, “Oh my God, think about doing one thing like that.” I used to be by no means ever pondering that that was even a risk. And it’s so cool that it’s actual as a result of when you may have youthful followers or individuals wanting as much as you, listeners, they will additionally simply see that and be like, “Oh, that would really be me, too.”
MICHAELS Particularly as a songwriter rising up with Shelly Peiken and Linda Perry, and all of the songwriters that wrote for all of your favourite pop artists. You’re like, “How do you try this? How do you even get there?” Then to have the ability to know them, write with them, be right here, it’s such a good looking factor.
RODRIGO Do you guys take into consideration that once you’re writing songs? I discover it extremely tough to consider it once I’m really within the means of it. I believe it doesn’t hit me, the affect of it, till months afterward tour or one thing. I take into consideration this rather a lot: Jon, in your Grammy speech just a few years in the past, you had been like, “I present up day-after-day; I make music day-after-day as a result of it’s a non secular follow for me.” That’s completely what it’s. If I don’t write day-after-day or create one thing, I don’t really feel like myself. I don’t really feel fulfilled. It doesn’t matter if I put it out. It’s one thing that that you must do, similar to respiration or consuming.
MICHAELS I really feel extra anxious once I don’t write.
LIPA It’s like an exorcism that occurs.
Jon Batiste
Let’s discuss these Barbie songs which have taken over all the world. The entire album is fireplace. Dua, what was it like creating “Dance the Night time”?
LIPA It was, from the very starting, probably the most enjoyable expertise. It was one thing that I hadn’t achieved earlier than. Mainly, the way in which it got here to be was Mark Ronson DM’d me on Instagram, which is bizarre as a result of we’re mates, so we textual content. He was like, “I’m engaged on this movie with Greta Gerwig and it’s Barbie, and it’s presumably the funniest script I’ve learn, and I really need you to put in writing the tune for the massive dance scene within the movie.” I used to be like, “That is an absolute no-brainer. One thousand % sure.” I used to be on tour on the time, so I used to be like, “OK, when does the tune should be due?” I flew to New York, we went within the studio, and we simply had a lot time speaking to Greta, understanding the premise of the movie. It’s a lot about stereotypical Barbie having an existential disaster and discovering out what it’s wish to expertise the human situation and the way in which that we’re as individuals and the feelings that we really feel. And continuously striving for perfection however not fairly reaching it, striving for one thing deeper in a approach. Greta was saying how impressed by disco she was. I simply considered disco and the neighborhood it brings, and the way in which it brings individuals collectively. It was all the time a style of music that was such a launch when issues weren’t going effectively on this planet. And so “Dance the Night time” was created particularly for Barbie’s greatest day ever, which then ends in her fascinated with demise. So it’s actually about these dualities of life and with the ability to merge the 2 collectively. And that’s what I like probably the most. I like dance-crying.
BATISTE I walked into the studio with Mark and I noticed all of y’all’s notes hanging on the wall.
LIPA Oh my God.
BATISTE The entire Barbie film is rather a lot. It’s very deep. Existential. Ooh! It’s very Whitman-esque. It’s acquired a complete bunch of stuff in it that’s beneath the floor. That’s what I like a couple of dance tune with an important lyric. You all the time have nice melodies and also you all the time make sure that the lyrics attain the extent of the melodies.
LIPA Thanks, my gosh.
EILISH I discover myself all through most of my days [singing “Dance the Night”]. It’s simply in my head rather a lot. It’s catchy, woman. It’s actually good.
And your Barbie tune, Billie —
BATISTE So what was …
ERIVO ( Batiste) Go on and ask her! You need to ask as a result of I’m about to do it myself. I need to know — why that development of be aware? (Begins singing the start of “What Was I Made For?”)
EILISH Dude.
ERIVO Instantly my coronary heart goes (motioning towards her coronary heart).
EILISH Thanks.
ERIVO The place had been you?
EILISH That’s the very first thing that I wrote — was that precise melody.
BATISTE First mile.
Julia Michaels
EILISH It was a wet day in January, and it was the day after we’d seen [Barbie] and it was darkish for me in my life. My brother and I had been working and attempting to make stuff for this album, and it was only a day of nothing. It was simply concept after concept after concept of simply no concepts. Nothing was occurring. It was the least inventive. We got here up with so many various issues, and it was an occasion the place we had been like, “Yeah, we’re scratching these. This isn’t even value our time.” I believe we had been doing that for most likely six hours. And it was about 8 p.m. and I used to be like, “All proper, effectively, I’m out of right here. I’m going to go residence. We’re achieved for the day. We tried.” After which [Finneas] was like, “Only for shits and giggles, what if we tried to put in writing that tune?” I used to be like, “What? You assume after the day of rubbish we’ve simply made, we’re going to make an ideal tune for one thing that wants one thing actually good?” I used to be like, “I don’t even have that in me.” To start with, I didn’t know I might have it in me in any respect. When it was introduced as much as me, I used to be like, “I imply, thanks for asking, however I don’t know if I can provide you what you’re going to wish. I would like you to have one thing astounding, and hopefully I can get near that, however I don’t know.” And Finneas sat on the piano and instantly began enjoying, and we’ve been utilizing a handheld mic within the room that simply performs by the audio system as an alternative of headphones. I by no means used a sales space or something.
RODRIGO So simply the previous SM [handheld mic].
EILISH I used to be sitting on just a little sofa with the hand-held and he was enjoying these chords and it was similar to (begins singing “What Was I Made For?”). We had been speaking rather a lot concerning the floating class of [Barbie] and her capability to be so clean and exquisite and excellent on a regular basis. After which the juxtaposition of her out of the blue falling and [she] can’t do the whole lot completely. So it was that, “I used to drift, now I simply fall down.” We wrote that after which, “I used to know, however I’m undecided now.” And I instantly was like: “What I used to be made for.” Then we had been each asking the query after that and we did that in most likely 5 minutes. It was prefer it was God. It was simply probably the most good instance to me of true inspiration and connection. It was dwelling in me that complete day, nevertheless it wasn’t popping out of me. We didn’t go into it realizing in any respect what we had been going to make or if we had been going to make something. And it was simply so clear that we wanted to. Such as you had been saying, Olivia, I like writing for movie. Not even simply movie however for one thing.
RODRIGO Proper.
EILISH I actually love an project. I’m listening to everyone speaking about songwriting, and ( Julia) you’re simply so good at it. For me, I discover songwriting very tough and honesty in songwriting very arduous and out of my attain. There’s one thing so particular to me about writing about not-my-life. I used to be like, “That is simply completely about one other woman, one other character, nothing to do with my life.”
ERIVO That was simply your mind and physique saying, “Attempt one thing else.”
EILISH The following day or two later, I performed it for a pal and we had been sitting within the automobile. I used to be like, “This bitch is singing about me!” And it was scary. I used to be shaky. It was like when you wakened and somebody had taken a photograph of you sleeping.
I thank God for Greta, man. I actually was involved that it was over for me. I’ve acquired to be sincere with you. She saved me, actually, actually. Getting that request, it was like a FaceTime, it introduced us each out of it, and instantly we had been impressed and wrote a lot extra after that. Particularly when it got here out, I used to be like, “Aye yai yai.” It was like any person studying your diary or one thing.
MICHAELS Did it unlock one thing in you the place you’re like, “Oh, I really may be extraordinarily weak and or not it’s obtained”?
EILISH Sure and no. However sure, as a result of the way in which that it was obtained was so stunning to me. I assume I neglect that everyone feels the identical in so some ways and that the whole lot we really feel any person is aware of.
MICHAELS It is probably not the identical factor, nevertheless it’s the identical emotion.
BATISTE Yeah — individuals.
EILISH And I used to be actually, actually moved by that. Particularly the way in which that [Barbie] introduced ladies collectively, [that] was like one thing that I really feel simply so happy with. I used to be like, “I really feel like I’m in the appropriate [place].” It felt actually cool.
MICHAELS Talking of girls, how superb is that this desk? To be doing this the place there actually is a lot camaraderie with ladies is so — excuse me, Jon — [cool]. Simply being at a desk with people who find themselves genuinely comfortable for one another is so thrilling.
EILISH It’s very true — I’m comfortable for you.
MICHAELS It truly is true. I like you all. I would like you all to win. It’s so sick.
Clockwise from high left: Jon Batiste, Billie Eilish, Cynthia Erivo, The Starvation Video games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, This Want and Dua Lipa
When attempting to ebook this panel, I used to be like, “Oh my God, we may have all these superb feminine songwriters on the roundtable.” For younger ladies to see all this illustration I believe is so key.
MICHAELS I agree.
BATISTE I noticed that once I acquired the invitation. I used to be like, “I need to come be taught from all of you.” I like what you mentioned concerning the diary and about bringing ladies collectively, particularly you’ve ( Eilish) been a voice on your era so profoundly. However I believe individuals need to learn your diary, however additionally they need to learn their diary.
RODRIGO That’s a great way to place it.
EILISH Sure, sure. And it seems possibly it’s the identical generally.
BATISTE It’s like, “Oh snap. We actually are linked.”
EILISH Do you ever have a lyric that you just really feel like is so private that you just’re like, “Ought to I alter it? They’re not going to grasp it,” after which they get it in a approach.
MICHAELS They internalize it.
EILISH They see you.
LIPA Once you had been speaking about virtually manifesting your personal life into the tune — does anyone else really feel that once you write, you’re virtually manifesting issues which can be about to occur?
MICHAELS Utterly.
LIPA Doesn’t it scare you that once you’re about to put in writing, you’re like, “Ought to I be placing this in a tune?”
MICHAELS It’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.
LIPA I really feel that a lot.
EILISH I really feel like I look again at songs that I relate to now greater than I ever did once I wrote them.
MICHAELS And a few songs tackle utterly new which means. That’s true.
RODRIGO I believe it’s proof that songs come from the divine — that generally they’ve issues that we don’t know.
EILISH That’s so true. We name it generally.
ERIVO The muse exhibits up.
BATISTE Howdy, vessel.
This roundtable has been condensed and edited for size and readability.
THR’s Oscar roundtables will air as Off Script With The Hollywood Reporter on AMC’s SundanceTV channel on Sundays from Dec. 31 by Jan. 14. Search for the whole roundtable movies on THR.com/Roundtables and YouTube after broadcast.
This story first appeared within the Nov. 16 concern of The Hollywood Reporter journal. Click on right here to subscribe.